1080 The FAN
Thursdays 10pm - 12am

Local: 503.250.1080
    Toll Free: 866.358.1080
| More
College Football

Emmert says NCAA will appeal O'Bannon ruling

(AP Photo/Eric Draper, File)


AP Sports Writer

(AP) -- Mark Emmert said Sunday that the NCAA will appeal a ruling that opens the door for college athletes to receive some of the money they help generate in major sports.

In the NCAA president's first public comments since Friday's ruling, Emmert told ABC's "This Week With George Stephanopoulos" that college sports' largest governing body found a lot in the decision that was "admirable" and some parts they disagreed with so strongly that they could not let it go unchallenged in court.

"Yes, at least in part we will," Emmert said when asked whether the NCAA planned an appeal. "No one on our legal team or the college conferences' legal teams think this is a violation of antitrust laws and we need to get that settled in the courts."

The NCAA's decision to challenge the ruling is hardly a surprise.

Donald Remy, the organization's chief legal officer, had repeatedly said that if the NCAA lost, it would appeal the case all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court if needed. Many legal experts think this case could be heading that direction, though it's unclear whether the nation's highest court would take it.

"We remain confident that the NCAA has not violated the antitrust laws and intend to appeal," Remy said in a statement released following the television show. "We will also be seeking clarity from the district court on some details of its ruling.""

Joseph Farelli, an attorney with the New York-based law firm of Pitta & Giblin who specializes in labor law, said the NCAA didn't have a choice after U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken on Friday shot down the NCAA's argument that its model of amateurism was the only way to run college sports. Wilken wrote that football players in FBS schools and Division I men's basketball players must be allowed to receive at least $5,000 a year for rights to their names, images and likenesses, money that would be put in a trust fund and given to them when they leave school.

"I would expect them to appeal it because now you're going to have a permanent injunction that says the NCAA can't regulate what colleges do with their student-athletes," Farelli told The Associated Press. "If they don't appeal, now you have a federal court precedent."

If the NCAA allowed that decision to stand, Farelli said, it could lead to even more litigation against the NCAA on hot-button topics such as Title IX and whether there should be any cap on how much money athletes should receive.

Emmert acknowledged Sunday that Wilken's decision could lead to a fundamental shift in college sports.

Historically, the NCAA fares better in the appellate system. According to a study released last month by Illinois professor Michael LeRoy, student-athletes suing the NCAA won 49 percent of the initial cases but the NCAA won 71 percent of the appeals in both the second and third rounds.

This time could be different because of the venue.

"The problem for the NCAA is that the appeal will be in the Ninth Circuit, and the Ninth Circuit is generally a labor-friendly circuit. Looking from the outside, it would likely favor O'Bannon," said Michael McCann, director of the sports and entertainment law center at the University of New Hampshire School of Law. "It depends on which judges get the case and we won't know that."

Emmert did applaud parts of the decision that allow the NCAA to enforce other rules and the imposition of the cap.

But by the time the payments are supposed to begin in 2016, the NCAA could be operating under new rules.

The board of directors voted Thursday to give the five richest conferences more authority to unilaterally change some of the rules, a move that paves the way for giving players enough money to defray all or most of their college expenses including those that go beyond current limit of tuition, room and board, books and fees.

"There's little debate about the need to do that," Emmert said, "and I think this move will finally allow us to get there."

Updated August 10, 2014

w11 © 2015 by STATS LLC and Associated Press.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and Associated Press is strictly prohibited.

The Fan's Top Stories

Oklahoma up to 3rd, Iowa 4th in playoff rankings; ND to 6th

(AP) Oklahoma moved into third and Iowa was fourth in the new College Football Playoff rankings as Notre Dame slipped to No. 6. More.

Manziel benched by Browns for off-field behavior

(AP) Dropped from starter to third-stringer - without playing a game. Johnny Manziel partied his way out of the lineup during Cleveland's bye week. Browns coach Mike Pettine . . . more.

Ducks finishing strong but can't rewrite season

(AP) Oregon can't dwell on what might have been this season, had quarterback Vernon Adams Jr. been healthy from the start. The No. 18 Ducks (8-3, 6-2 Pac-12) need to prepare . . . more.

Bender may get 1st start for No. 20 Cougars in Apple Cup

(AP) Peyton Bender was somewhat of an unknown in high school when he traveled from sunny south Florida to chilly eastern Washington to throw the football for Mike Leach. More.

Elliott says he is out after Ohio State upset by Michigan St

(AP) Ezekiel Elliott played his last game at Ohio Stadium on Saturday. Carrying the ball 12 times during a wet and windy last-second loss was not how he planned to go out. More.

Rawls runs for 209 yards as Seahawks beat 49ers

(AP) About two hours before kickoff Seattle's Thomas Rawls was in the locker room getting loosened up. He was told Marshawn Lynch wouldn't be able to play. Suddenly helping . . . more.

Brooks, Dorsey lead No. 25 Ducks past Valpo

(AP) Oregon's Dillon Brooks stood at midcourt, arms stretched wide, indignant over what he was certain had been a phantom foul call on him while defending Alec Peters' 3-pointer. More.

Oregon State eases by UC Santa Barbara 71-59

(AP) Gary Payton II made three of Oregon State's 10 3-pointers and finished with 21 points to help the Beavers beat UC Santa Barbara 71-59 on Saturday night. More.

The FAN's NFL Page

From the games, to the hot stories and the player moves, The FAN's NFL Page has everything you need for your favorite team, your fantasy team and more.

The FAN's NBA Page

As the NBA season tips off, you'll find the latest on the new-lookTrail Blazers and headlines, game casts, previews and recaps for all teams on The FAN's NBA page.

The FAN's Golf Page

The FAN's Golf Page is where you can go for the latest AP coverage of the PGA, LPGA, Web.Com, European and Champion's Tour info. From leader boards to stories, it's all right here.